The Bean SchoolShop Artisan Bean(opens in a new tab)

The guide

Brewing

Good coffee is mostly not about equipment. It is about four variables — grind size, the ratio of coffee to water, the water itself, and temperature — and about adjusting them in a sensible order when a cup tastes wrong. This guide explains each of those, then gives concrete recipes for the six brewers that most people actually use, with the mistakes that ruin them.

About 22 minutes

You do not need a scale, a gooseneck kettle or a shelf of gear to make good coffee, but a set of kitchen scales and a burr grinder will do more for your cup than any machine you can buy. Everything below is written for someone making coffee at home, on ordinary equipment, without a commercial background.

If you only read one section, read the one on extraction. It explains why a cup tastes sour or bitter, which is the question most people actually have.

01

Grind size

Grind is the single biggest lever you have, and the one most people never touch.

Water extracts flavour from the surface of the coffee, so the smaller the pieces, the faster everything happens. A fine grind gives up its flavour in twenty seconds; a coarse one takes minutes. That is why the same beans can taste sour in one brewer and sweet in another, and why grind size is the first thing to change when a cup is wrong.

The reference points worth knowing: espresso is a fine powder, like icing sugar; pour-over and drip sit around medium-fine, like table salt; AeroPress a touch finer than drip; French press is coarse, like sea salt or raw sugar; cold brew is coarser than that, closer to gravel. Moka pot sits between espresso and drip. These are starting points, not settings — every grinder has its own numbering, and a “medium” on one machine can be “fine” on another.

Consistency matters more than exactness. A blade grinder chops beans into a mix of powder and boulders, so the fine part over-extracts while the coarse part under-extracts, and the cup tastes both sour and bitter at once. A burr grinder crushes to a more even size, which is why it is the upgrade worth making before anything else. If you use pre-ground coffee, buy it ground for your brewer and use it within a week.

Grind also drifts. Beans change as they age and as the roast level changes: dark roasts are brittle and grind finer for the same setting, light ones are dense and need a finer setting anyway. If a bag that brewed well last week suddenly runs slow, it is usually the coffee, not you.

02

Ratio

The ratio of coffee to water sets how strong the cup is. It does not set how well it is brewed — that is a different variable, and confusing the two is the most common mistake in coffee.

Weigh everything. A tablespoon of coffee can weigh anywhere from four to seven grams depending on the bean, the roast and how heaped the spoon is, which is a fifty per cent difference before you start. Kitchen scales that read to a gram cost very little and remove the guesswork entirely.

For filter coffee, the usual range is around 1:15 to 1:17 coffee to water by weight — that is, 60 grams of coffee per litre of water, or 15 grams to 250 grams. Stronger is 1:15; lighter is 1:17. Espresso is a different animal, around 1:2 in to out: 18 grams of coffee yielding 36 grams of liquid. Moka pot sits around 1:10. Cold brew is a concentrate, usually 1:5 to 1:8 before diluting.

Remember that the grounds keep water. Roughly two grams of water stay behind for every gram of coffee, so 15 grams of coffee and 250 grams of water gives you about 220 grams in the cup, not 250. That matters when you compare a recipe to what you actually poured.

The distinction that matters: changing the ratio changes strength, while changing grind, time or temperature changes extraction. If your coffee tastes weak but pleasant, use more coffee. If it tastes sour or bitter, the ratio is not your problem.

03

Water

Coffee is about 98 per cent water, and water that tastes of nothing makes coffee that tastes of nothing.

You cannot brew good coffee from bad water. If your tap water tastes of chlorine or metal, so will the coffee, only more so. A simple filter jug removes the chlorine and much of the off-tastes, and is the cheapest improvement most kitchens can make.

Mineral content matters too, in both directions. Water that is too soft — distilled, or heavily filtered — tastes flat and can make coffee taste sour and hollow, because there is nothing in it to carry the flavour. Water that is too hard leaves scale and makes a dull, chalky cup. The commonly cited target for brewing is somewhere around 50–150 ppm of hardness, with alkalinity low, around 40 ppm. Most decent tap water sits inside or near that; very hard water does not.

Alkalinity is the part worth understanding, because it buffers acidity: high-alkalinity water flattens a bright coffee and makes it taste dull and chalky. If your coffee always tastes muted whatever you do, try a bottle of low-mineral water once and see whether the fruit comes back. It is a cheap experiment.

Avoid softened water, which swaps calcium for sodium and tastes of it, and avoid pure distilled water in an espresso machine. Beyond that, do not overthink it: tap water that tastes good, run through a filter, is fine.

04

Temperature

Hot enough to extract, not so hot that it burns — which in practice means just off the boil for most brewers.

Most filter coffee is brewed between 90 and 96 °C. Water boils at 100 °C at sea level, a little lower as you climb, and “just off the boil” lands around 93–96. If you have no thermometer, that is a perfectly good guide: boil the kettle, take it off, and count to thirty before you pour.

Roast level shifts the target. Light roasts are dense and resist extraction, so they want the hotter end, 94–96 °C. Dark roasts are porous and give up their flavour easily, so slightly cooler water, 88–92 °C, keeps them from turning bitter and ashy. A medium roast sits in the middle and is happy anywhere in the band.

Temperature also drops the moment you pour. A cold brewer, a cold mug or a cold room steals heat from the water before it reaches the coffee, which is why preheating a ceramic pour-over cone or a French press with hot water is worth the few seconds it takes. Espresso machines hold temperature at the group, usually 90–96 °C, and a machine that cannot hold it steady will never be consistent however good your grinder is.

Cold brew is the exception: it uses time instead of heat, over twelve to eighteen hours. More on that in the method below.

05

Reading the cup

When a cup tastes wrong, the answer is almost always under- or over-extraction — and the two taste nothing alike.

Extraction is how much of the coffee has dissolved into the water. Too little and you get sourness, saltiness, a thin body and a quick finish — the acids come out first. Too much and you get bitterness, dryness, astringency and a hollow middle, because the bitter compounds come out last. In the middle is sweetness, and that is what you are aiming for.

A rough rule of thumb used across the trade is that filter coffee lands somewhere around 18–22 per cent of the grounds dissolving, at a strength around 1.15–1.45 per cent dissolved solids. You do not need to measure that at home. You need the direction: sour and thin means extract more, bitter and dry means extract less.

To extract more, grind finer, use hotter water, brew longer, or stir more. To extract less, do the opposite. Change one thing at a time and taste again, or you will never know which one worked. Grind is usually the best single lever, because it changes extraction a lot and is easy to undo.

Two traps. First, strength is not extraction: a weak but sour cup needs more coffee and more extraction at once, and a strong but bitter one needs dilution and less extraction. Second, water and beans set a ceiling: no recipe rescues stale beans or bad water, and a light roast brewed like a dark one will taste sour however carefully you work.

06

The methods

Six brewers, each with a starting recipe and the mistakes that most often ruin it. The numbers are starting points, not laws — your grinder, your water and your taste will move them, and the recipes assume fresh beans and scales.

V60 and pour-over

The everyday filter method — clean, bright and unforgiving

Grind
Medium-fine, like table salt
Ratio
15 g coffee to 250 g water (about 1:16.7)
Water
92–96 °C
Time
2:30–3:30, including the bloom

A cone with a paper filter, brewed in stages by pouring water over the grounds. The paper holds back the oils and the finest particles, which gives the cleanest, clearest cup of any method here and the one that shows an origin most plainly. It is also the least forgiving: a pour-over punishes a bad grinder and rewards attention.

A reliable starting recipe: rinse the paper with hot water and warm the cone, then discard that water. Add 15 g of medium-fine coffee, level it, and pour about 45–50 g of water — roughly three times the coffee's weight — to saturate the grounds. Wait 30–45 seconds while it bubbles; that is the coffee releasing carbon dioxide, and it lets the rest of the water through evenly. Then pour in two or three stages up to 250 g, keeping the water level steady and the bed of coffee flat, and give the cone a gentle swirl at the end. Everything should finish somewhere between two and a half and three and a half minutes.

If it finishes faster than about 2:15 the grind is too coarse and the cup will be thin and sour; grind finer. If it stalls past about 3:45, or the water sits on top and will not drain, the grind is too fine, or there are too many fines in it — grind coarser. Those two adjustments fix most pour-over problems.

Common mistakes

Grinding too fine and stalling the brew; pouring all the water in at once and leaving the bed uneven; skipping the bloom; not rinsing the paper, which leaves a papery taste; using beans more than two months old and wondering why it tastes flat; and guessing at quantities instead of weighing.

French press

Full immersion, full body, no paper

Grind
Coarse, like sea salt or raw sugar
Ratio
30 g coffee to 500 g water (about 1:16.7)
Water
95 °C, just off the boil
Time
4 minutes steeping, then press

The simplest brewer there is: a jug, a metal mesh filter and a plunger. The coffee steeps in the water for minutes rather than being poured through, and because the mesh lets the oils and the finest particles through, the cup is heavier, rounder and muddier than a pour-over, with less clarity but more body. If you like your coffee with milk, or you find filter coffee thin, this is the method to try.

Recipe: warm the press, add 30 g of coarsely ground coffee, pour on 500 g of water just off the boil, and stir once so all the grounds are wet. Put the lid on with the plunger pulled up and leave it four minutes. Then press down slowly and steadily — if it fights back, the grind is too fine — and pour all of it out at once, straight away, into cups or a jug.

If you want more clarity and less sludge, steep for five minutes, stir the crust of grounds on top, skim off the foam and floating particles with a spoon, then wait two more minutes before pressing. It sounds fussy, but it noticeably cleans up the cup.

Common mistakes

Grinding fine, which gives a sludgy cup and a plunger that will not go down; leaving the brewed coffee sitting on the grounds after pressing, where it keeps extracting and turns bitter within minutes; pressing hard and fast; not preheating the press; and using a blade grinder, whose fines go straight through the mesh.

AeroPress

The forgiving hybrid — immersion plus a push

Grind
Medium-fine, a little finer than drip
Ratio
15 g coffee to 220 g water (about 1:14.7)
Water
85–95 °C
Time
1:30–2:00 in total

A tube, a plunger and a paper or metal filter. It brews by immersion and then pushes the coffee through the filter under hand pressure, which makes it fast, tolerant and easy to travel with. It is the method most likely to give a decent cup on the first attempt, which makes it a good place to start if you are learning.

Standard method: rinse a paper filter and set it in the cap. Stand the AeroPress on a sturdy mug, add 15 g of medium-fine coffee, pour in 220 g of water at 85–95 °C, and stir gently so all the grounds are wet. At about 1:30, screw on the cap and press down slowly over 20–30 seconds. Stop when you hear the hiss of air — pushing past that only adds bitter compounds.

Two useful variations. Inverted, with the plunger at the top of the tube, you can fill and steep for two minutes without anything dripping through, then flip and press; that gives you more control. And concentrate style, 18 g of coffee to 120 g of water, pressed and then diluted with hot water or milk, gives something closer to espresso in strength if not in character.

Common mistakes

Grinding too fine, which makes it hard to press and produces a muddy, over-extracted cup; pressing too hard and fast; not stirring, so half the grounds stay dry; skipping the filter rinse; and filling past the top, which spills when you insert the plunger.

Moka pot

The stovetop classic — strong, cheap and easy to get wrong

Grind
Finer than drip, coarser than espresso
Ratio
Basket holds what it holds — roughly 1:10 in the pot
Water
Preheated, just off the boil
Time
3–5 minutes on low heat

Two chambers screwed together: water below, coffee in a basket above, and steam pressure pushes the water up through the grounds. It makes a strong, thick, slightly cloudy coffee — closer to espresso in strength than to filter, though it is not espresso and will not have the same crema or the same clarity. It costs little, lasts decades and needs no electricity.

Recipe: fill the basket level with coarsely ground coffee and do not tamp it — levelling off the top with a finger is all it needs. Fill the base with water to just below the safety valve, and use preheated water if you can, so the coffee spends less time being heated before the water arrives. Screw the top on firmly. Put it on a low to medium flame with the lid open so you can watch, and take it off the heat the moment it starts to gurgle and hiss, running the base under cool water to stop the extraction. Waiting for it to sputter to the end is what makes moka pot taste burnt and rubbery.

Grind is the fiddly part: too fine and the pressure cannot push through, which gives a dry, half-empty pot and a bitter cup; too coarse and it tastes weak and under-extracted. Aim between espresso and drip. And keep the gasket clean and replace it when it hardens, or it will leak and under-extract.

Common mistakes

Tamping or packing the basket; using high heat, which scorches the grounds; leaving it on the heat until it hisses itself dry; not screwing it tight enough so it leaks; and washing an aluminium pot in a dishwasher, which dulls it.

Espresso

The one that needs a machine — and a grinder to match

Grind
Very fine, like icing sugar
Ratio
18 g in, 36 g out (about 1:2)
Water
90–96 °C at the group
Time
25–30 seconds

Espresso forces water through a packed bed of fine coffee at around nine bar, which is why it is the only method here that needs a machine. The result is a small, strong, concentrated cup with a layer of foam on top and a texture no other brewer produces. It is also the most equipment-sensitive method by a wide margin, and the one where the grinder matters most.

The usual modern starting point: 18 g of finely ground coffee in a double basket, yielding about 36 g of liquid in 25–30 seconds. Fix the dose and the ratio, then adjust only the grind: finer if it runs fast and tastes sour, coarser if it runs slow and tastes bitter or dry. Change one variable at a time and taste, because the shot time alone tells you little — a shot can run in 25 seconds and still be wrong.

Two things are worth knowing before you spend anything. First, home espresso is expensive to do well: the machine and the grinder are both critical, and a cheap grinder will limit a good machine. Second, you do not need to own one. A good café will make you a better espresso than most home setups, and everything else in this guide is cheaper and easier to learn on. If you do buy, buy the grinder first.

Common mistakes

Stale beans, which cannot produce a stable shot whatever you do; an inadequate grinder, the most common reason home espresso disappoints; judging a shot by time alone rather than by weight and taste; not weighing the output; a dirty machine or a hard, neglected gasket; and expecting a cheap machine to match a café.

Espresso is the one method here that needs a guide of its own — Espresso at home covers the gear, dialling in, milk and the thirteen faults that account for most bad shots.

Cold brew

Time instead of heat — smooth, sweet and easy to get wrong

Grind
Coarse, like raw sugar or sea salt
Ratio
1:5 to 1:8 as a concentrate, dilute to taste
Water
Cold, from the fridge or the tap
Time
12–18 hours

Cold water extracts coffee too, just slowly. Over twelve to eighteen hours it pulls out the sugars and much of the body while leaving behind some of the acids and bitter compounds that hot water produces, which is why cold brew tastes rounder, sweeter and more chocolatey than the same beans brewed hot and chilled. It is a genuinely different drink, not just cold coffee.

Recipe: 100 g of coarsely ground coffee to 500 g of cold water — a 1:5 concentrate — stirred so all the grounds are wet, covered, and left in the fridge for sixteen to eighteen hours, or at room temperature for twelve. Then strain through a paper filter or a fine cloth; a metal sieve alone leaves sludge. The concentrate keeps in the fridge for a week or two. Dilute it with water or milk to taste, usually around one to one, and pour over ice.

Room temperature brews faster and a little harsher; the fridge is slower and cleaner. Either works, but be consistent so you can adjust. And do not assume cold brew is low in caffeine: a concentrate at 1:5 is strong stuff, and a large glass of it can carry more caffeine than a filter cup.

Common mistakes

Grinding fine, which gives a sludgy, muddy concentrate that is hard to filter; leaving it out at room temperature for a day or more, which turns it woody and bitter; not filtering properly; diluting nothing and drinking concentrate by the mug; and keeping it past a couple of weeks in the fridge.

07

How to use all this

Pick one method, weigh your coffee and water, and keep everything else still for a week. Then change one thing — grind, then ratio, then temperature — and taste the difference. That is the whole of learning to brew, and it takes less time than reading about it.

The order that works: fresh beans, a burr grinder, scales, decent water, and then practice. Everything else is a preference. A careful French press of good beans will beat a careless espresso of great ones, and no piece of equipment makes up for coffee that was roasted four months ago.

Back to the home page — or read Origins & Regions and Roasts, or Buying coffee for choosing a bag by the brewer you own, or look up a word in the Glossary. If you are heading for espresso, read Espresso at home, and Water for what the other 98 per cent of the cup is doing; if you have heard something about coffee that sounds too neat, check Coffee myths; and once you have brewed something you like, How to taste shows you what to notice in it. And if the cup in front of you tastes bitter, sour, watery or burnt, Troubleshooting takes each fault in the order worth trying.