The Bean SchoolShop Artisan Bean(opens in a new tab)

The guide

Water

A cup of filter coffee is around 98 per cent water. Espresso is closer to nine parts water to one part coffee. Whatever is in that water ends up in the cup, and whatever the water does to the grounds decides what comes out of them — which is why changing nothing but the water can change a cup more than a new grinder does.

About 18 minutes

This guide covers the two things in water that matter most, hardness and alkalinity, and explains why they are not the same thing. It covers chlorine, which is a fault you can fix for the price of a filter jug, and scale, which is a fault that eventually costs you a machine. Then it covers the three routes — tap, bottled, or water you build yourself — and the fixes that need no equipment and no numbers at all.

Nothing here requires a laboratory or a test kit. Most of it can be worked out by brewing two cups side by side and tasting them, which is the method this guide would recommend even if you had the equipment.

01

Why water is most of the cup

You would not make soup with water you would not drink, and coffee is the same bargain at a much larger scale.

Weigh a brew and the arithmetic is stark. A pour-over at 60 grams of coffee to a litre of water produces a little over a litre of coffee, of which roughly 12 to 15 grams is dissolved coffee solids. The rest is the water you put in. Espresso is more concentrated — a shot is roughly one part coffee solids to nine parts water — but it is still mostly water, and the water is still the thing every flavour compound is dissolved in.

That matters because water is not a neutral carrier. It is a solvent with its own chemistry, and that chemistry does two separate jobs in a brew. It extracts: the minerals dissolved in water are what attach to the flavour compounds in the grounds and pull them into the cup. And it buffers: some of what is dissolved in water neutralises the acids in coffee, which is the difference between a bright cup and a flat one. Neither job is about the water tasting of anything itself.

It also carries faults. Anything in your water that has a taste — chlorine, metal, the plastic of a cheap bottle left in the sun — will be in the cup, and coffee's own flavours do not cover it up. A chlorinated cup tastes of chlorine first and coffee second.

The practical consequence is that water is the cheapest variable in coffee. Beans cost money, grinders cost more, and a new brewer costs more again. A filter jug, a bottle of distilled water from a supermarket, or simply a different tap can change the cup for a few pounds, and it is the first thing worth checking when the coffee you know well has started tasting wrong.

02

Hardness: the minerals that do the extracting

Hardness is dissolved calcium and magnesium, and it is the part of water that reaches into the grounds and brings flavour out.

Hard water is water that has passed through limestone or chalk and picked up calcium and magnesium on the way. It is measured as an equivalent weight of calcium carbonate, usually in milligrams per litre, which is the same as parts per million — so 120 mg/L and 120 ppm mean the same thing. Your water supplier will quote it in one of several units, and they are all convertible; more on that later.

Those two minerals are the ones that bind to the aromatic and acidic compounds in coffee and carry them into solution. Take them away entirely and extraction stalls: coffee brewed with distilled or reverse-osmosis water tends to taste hollow, thin and woody, sometimes oddly sweet in a papery way, because the water has nothing with which to lift the flavour out of the grounds. It is a common surprise that the purest water makes the worst coffee.

Push the other way and hardness becomes a problem of its own. Very hard water produces a cup that tastes chalky, drying and minerally, with a heaviness that sits on the tongue, and it mutes the finer aromatics underneath. It also leaves scale, which is the subject of a later section and the more expensive half of the problem.

So there is a middle band rather than a direction. Water with some hardness makes coffee taste of more; water with none makes it taste of less; water with a great deal makes it taste of the water. Where exactly the band sits is genuinely contested — published recipes differ, and so do palates — but the shape of the curve is not in doubt, and you can find your own place on it by taste.

One footnote that gets repeated as fact more often than it deserves: magnesium is frequently said to extract fruit acids and aromatics more effectively than calcium, and it is a plausible claim with some experimental support behind it. Treat it as a tendency rather than a settled rule. Both minerals extract, and the difference between them is much smaller than the difference between having some hardness and having none.

03

Alkalinity: the part that flattens coffee

Alkalinity is water's capacity to neutralise acid, and it is the single most common reason good coffee tastes dull at home.

Alkalinity is not the same as alkaline, and it is not the same as pH, though the three get used interchangeably in coffee talk and the confusion costs people a lot of wasted effort. Alkalinity measures how much acid the water can absorb before its own acidity changes. In most tap water it comes from bicarbonate, picked up as rainwater passes through chalk and limestone — the same geology that gives you hardness, which is why the two often arrive together.

Coffee is acidic. The brightness, the fruit, the citrus edge that makes a Kenyan coffee taste like a Kenyan coffee are all acids, and bicarbonate neutralises them on contact. Water with high alkalinity therefore lands in the cup as a flattening agent: the cup smells fine, and then tastes of not very much, with a drying, chalky, faintly soapy finish where the fruit used to be. The coffee has not changed. The water has eaten the part you were paying for.

This is the fault to suspect when every coffee you brew tastes muted in the same way, whatever the origin, the roast or the method. It is also the fault that grinding finer cannot fix, because extracting more of everything just gives you more of the same flatness, plus bitterness. People spend months buying brighter coffees to compensate for water that is removing the brightness, and the coffees never stand a chance.

Very low alkalinity is a fault in the other direction. With nothing to buffer them, the acids come through unmoderated and the cup tastes sharp, sour and thin, sometimes harsh at the back of the throat — and because it reads like under-extraction, it sends people chasing grind settings that never quite work. Soft water with low alkalinity and high hardness can produce this: plenty of minerals to extract, nothing to soften the result.

The pair is what you have to hold together. Hardness decides how much flavour you get out of the grounds; alkalinity decides how much of it survives into the cup. A water can be soft and alkaline, or hard and low in alkalinity, and those two waters make very different coffee even though both are perfectly good drinking water.

04

The numbers people quote, and how far to trust them

There is a widely used set of brewing targets, and it is a useful centre rather than a law of nature.

The most quoted guidance comes from the Specialty Coffee Association, whose water standard sets out a band for the things that matter: total dissolved solids somewhere around 75 to 250 mg/L, hardness in the region of 50 to 175, alkalinity roughly 40 to 70, and a pH between about 6.5 and 7.5. Various roasters and equipment makers publish their own versions, usually a little tighter, and water recipes sold for coffee are built to sit inside them.

Read those as a description of the middle of the road rather than a target to hit. The bands are wide because taste is personal and because a coffee's roast level shifts what suits it: a dense light roast tends to want more hardness and a little more alkalinity to round it out, a dark roast is easily overwhelmed by either. Two drinkers with the same water will disagree about whether it is too soft. What the numbers are genuinely good for is telling you which of the faults above you are likely to have.

pH deserves a note because people chase it. In practice pH matters much less than alkalinity, because coffee itself is acidic enough to drag the pH of the mixture down within moments of contact. Water at pH 8 and water at pH 6.5 can both make good coffee, while two waters at the same pH but different alkalinity will taste quite different. If you have one number to care about, it is alkalinity.

Then there is the cheap TDS pen, which is the piece of equipment most likely to mislead. It does not measure dissolved solids; it measures electrical conductivity and estimates solids from that. It cannot tell you whether the reading is hardness, bicarbonate, sodium or chloride, and those are the distinctions that decide how your coffee tastes. Where a pen is genuinely useful is as a crude check that a filter is working, or that a reverse-osmosis unit is producing water with almost nothing in it.

One honest caveat on all of this: the chemistry of extraction is well established, but the mapping from a number to a flavour is not. Published water recipes disagree with each other, and some of the confidence in the speciality literature runs ahead of the evidence. Use the numbers to locate yourself, then use your mouth.

05

Chlorine, chloramine, and the fault a filter fixes

If your coffee tastes medicinal, plastic or faintly of a swimming pool, stop reading about minerals and fix the chlorine first.

Most municipal water is disinfected, usually with chlorine or with chloramine, and this is a good thing: it is why the water is safe to drink. The trouble is that chlorine reacts with compounds in coffee to form chlorophenols, which the nose reads as medicinal, sticking-plaster, plastic, ink or disinfectant. The amounts involved are tiny and the effect is not — a cup made with chlorinated water can smell of the treatment plant even when a glass of the same water tastes of nothing.

Chlorine is easy to get rid of because it is volatile. Fill a jug and leave it uncovered overnight and most of it will have gone; boil the water and it goes faster. That is why the old advice to let water stand before brewing is not a myth, though it only solves this one problem and does nothing for hardness, alkalinity or anything else.

Chloramine is the harder case, and it is increasingly common because it survives longer in the pipes. It is chlorine combined with ammonia, it does not boil off, and leaving it standing does not remove it either. It needs carbon with enough contact time — a carbon block filter, or a jug filter used slowly and changed on schedule — and even then removal varies between products. If your supplier uses chloramine, it is worth checking what a filter actually claims before buying it, and worth using a filter that is specified for it.

The practical upshot: a carbon filter jug is the cheapest meaningful upgrade in home coffee, because it reliably removes chlorine and the musty, earthy, plastic notes that come with it. It is also the fix that requires the least understanding. Change the cartridge when the maker says to; a spent filter is worse than none, because it can start putting back what it was taking out.

06

Scale, softeners and the machine

The same minerals that make coffee taste of more will, given heat and time, turn into a layer of rock inside your kettle.

Calcium carbonate is less soluble in hot water than in cold, so heating hard water precipitates it as scale. You see the result as a furred kettle, a chalky element, and eventually a white crust in the bottom of a machine. In a kettle this is a nuisance that also changes the water you pour, because the minerals you wanted have been left behind on the element rather than going into the brew. In an espresso machine it is serious: scale builds in boilers, narrow pipes, valves and sensors, insulates the heating element, restricts flow and is a common cause of expensive failure.

So hard water asks for a decision. You can remove the minerals before the water goes in, blend your tap with low-mineral water to dilute them, or accept the scale and descale on a schedule. Descale a kettle with citric acid or a proprietary descaler — it is cheap and quick — and follow the machine maker's instructions for the machine rather than improvising, because the wrong descaler on the wrong seals is an expensive experiment.

Water softeners are the most misunderstood fix. A conventional ion-exchange softener swaps calcium and magnesium for sodium, which stops scale forming but does not remove anything from the water; it just changes what is in it. For coffee that is a trade: the scale problem goes away, and the cup can taste flat or faintly salty because sodium does not extract the way calcium and magnesium do. It is a reasonable choice for protecting plumbing and a compromised one for flavour.

At the other extreme, distilled and reverse-osmosis water have had almost everything removed. They make hollow coffee, and in an espresso machine they are a further risk, because water with no buffering capacity is more aggressive towards metal and many manufacturers advise against it or require it to be remineralised. Pure water is not the ideal; water with the right minerals in sensible amounts is.

None of this needs to be exact. If your kettle furs up within a few weeks, your water is hard enough to matter, and it is hard enough to affect the cup as well as the machine. That is a useful test you can run without buying anything.

07

Finding out what is in your water

You can learn most of what you need from your supplier's published report or a few pounds of aquarium test strips.

Water suppliers publish water quality data, usually as an annual report searchable by postcode or supply zone. Look for hardness and alkalinity, or bicarbonate, which is the thing alkalinity is calculated from. The reports often give ranges rather than a single figure, because water from different sources is blended, and the numbers can shift through the year — which is worth knowing, because it explains the occasional week when your coffee tastes different for no reason you can see.

The units are the obstacle. Milligrams per litre and parts per million are the same thing. A German degree of hardness is about 17.8 mg/L as calcium carbonate, a French degree is 10, and a grain per US gallon is about 17.1. Reports sometimes use words instead — soft, slightly hard, moderately hard, hard, very hard — and the boundaries between them differ by country, so a phrase is a rough guide and a number is better.

For a direct measurement, aquarium test strips are the practical answer. They are sold to fish keepers in two kinds: GH strips measure general hardness, which is calcium and magnesium, and KH strips measure carbonate hardness, which is a good stand-in for alkalinity. They are not precise, they read in broad steps, and they degrade with age, but they will tell you whether your water is soft or hard, and whether its alkalinity is low or high. That is enough to choose a fix.

If you would rather not measure anything, brew the test instead. Make two cups of the same coffee, with the same dose, grind, water volume and temperature, one with your tap water and one with a low-mineral bottled water. Taste them side by side, ideally without knowing which is which. If they are clearly different, your water is doing something, and the description of the difference tells you what: duller and less fruity points at alkalinity, thinner and sourer points at softness, a plastic or medicinal note points at chlorine. If you cannot tell them apart, water is not your problem, and you can stop worrying about it and go back to grind and beans.

08

Tap, bottled, or water you build yourself

All three routes work. They differ in cost, in effort, and in how much you want to know about what you are drinking.

Tap water is the sensible default, and in much of the world it is perfectly good for coffee. Run it through a carbon filter to deal with chlorine, and if it is soft and low in alkalinity you are largely done. If it is hard and alkaline, you have three options: blend it with low-mineral water, filter it with a reverse-osmosis unit, or accept a duller cup and descale more often. Filtering is also the cheapest of these, and it gives you better drinking water at the same time.

Bottled water is not automatically better, and the label is the whole story. Some mineral waters are harder and more alkaline than the worst tap water in the country, and will make coffee duller than your kitchen tap does. What you want on the label is modest hardness and low bicarbonate — a soft spring water is often a decent bet, and a cheap low-mineral water is usually better for coffee than an expensive one with a grand mineral profile. Distilled water from a supermarket or car accessory shop is the opposite case: it has nothing in it, so it makes flat coffee on its own, but it is the ideal starting point if you intend to add minerals yourself.

Bottled water also costs money and plastic for something that comes out of a pipe, and it is worth being honest about that. Its real use is as a test, as an occasional fix, or as the base for water you build yourself. If you find a cheap one you like, buying it by the litre for coffee is a legitimate choice; it is just not the only one.

Building your own is the third route, and it is less intimidating than it sounds. You start with water that has nothing in it — distilled or reverse-osmosis — and add back two things: a little Epsom salt for hardness and a very little baking soda for alkalinity. Epsom salt is magnesium sulfate, which supplies the hardness; baking soda is sodium bicarbonate, which supplies the buffer. Both are cheap, both dissolve completely, and a litre of water needs so little of either that a teaspoon measure is more than enough precision. Sachets of pre-mixed minerals are sold for exactly this purpose if you would rather not measure.

The trade is control for fiddliness. You get a repeatable water that you can tune to a coffee and to your own taste, and you get it for pennies a litre once the distilled water is bought. What you do not get is simplicity, and it is easy to overdo the minerals and end up with a chalky cup you cannot diagnose. Start with less than you think you need, and if you are not weighing, keep it to a pinch of each per litre and adjust by taste rather than by number. Published water recipes are a reasonable starting point and disagree with each other enough that you should treat any one of them as a suggestion.

09

Practical fixes, in order

Fix chlorine first, then alkalinity, then hardness — and only as far as your palate asks you to.

Start with a filter. A carbon jug filter or an inline filter on the tap deals with chlorine and its associated off-flavours for very little money, and it is the single most likely improvement for most kitchens. Change the cartridge on schedule. If your supplier uses chloramine rather than chlorine, check the filter is specified for it, and let it filter slowly.

If your water is hard or alkaline, dilute it. Blending tap water half and half with distilled or low-mineral bottled water cuts both hardness and alkalinity roughly in half, which is often enough to bring a dull cup back without any measuring. It is a good first experiment because it is reversible and it tells you immediately whether you are on the right track: if a 50/50 blend tastes better, you know which direction to go.

Boiling and cooling is a partial fix that costs nothing. Heating hard water precipitates some of its calcium bicarbonate as scale, so boiled-and-cooled water is a little softer and a little less alkaline than the water that went into the kettle. It is not a solution — the effect is limited, and whatever does not precipitate is left more concentrated because some water has boiled off — but if you are boiling the kettle anyway, it is a small improvement rather than a small harm.

Do not filter into emptiness. If you use reverse osmosis or distilled water, either blend it back with some tap water or add minerals, or the coffee will taste hollow and you will blame the beans. And do not use softened water expecting an improvement in flavour: it protects your plumbing and does little for the cup.

Then stop. Water is worth fixing to the point where the faults are gone; past that, chasing a number on a strip is a way of not drinking coffee. If a filtered tap makes a cup you enjoy, you have finished, and the next improvement is fresher beans, a better grinder, or practice.

10

The signs that water is what is wrong

Water faults have a signature: they follow the water rather than the coffee, and they repeat whatever you change.

The strongest signal is repetition. If every coffee you brew tastes muted in the same way — a bag of Kenyan, a bag of Brazilian, a light roast and a dark one, pour-over and French press — the common factor is the water, not the beans. Grind and ratio change the cup in different directions depending on the coffee; a water fault flattens everything the same way.

The second signal is comparison. If the same beans taste better at a friend's house, at a café, or on holiday, and you brewed them the same way, their water is doing something yours is not. This is worth taking seriously rather than dismissing as a nice cup out: it is a controlled experiment you have already run.

Then the specific notes. A medicinal, sticking-plaster, plastic or swimming-pool smell, especially as the cup cools, means chlorine or chloramine. A chalky, drying, minerally finish with white fur in the kettle means hardness. A cup that smells promising and then tastes of almost nothing, with a papery or soapy tail, means alkalinity. A cup that is sharp, sour and thin no matter how you grind means very soft water or low alkalinity, and if the sourness will not respond to a finer grind or hotter water at all, that is a strong hint the water is setting the ceiling.

Two more worth knowing. Espresso that looks right — good colour, sensible flow, a shot that took about the right time — but tastes hollow and empty is often a water problem rather than a puck problem, and it is easy to spend a fortune on baskets and tampers before testing it. And a cup that changes character for no apparent reason, without a new bag or a new grinder, can be the water supply itself: suppliers switch sources and blend differently through the year, and the water coming out of your tap in March is not always the water that came out in January.

11

How to use all this

The short version: filter your tap water for chlorine, find out roughly how hard and how alkaline it is, and if it is hard or alkaline, blend it down or buy a low-mineral bottled water for coffee. If you want more control than that, build water from distilled and a pinch of minerals. If you want less, a filter jug and a bag of beans you like is a perfectly respectable place to stop.

What you should not do is treat water as a problem to be solved exactly. The faults are real and worth fixing — chlorine is a fault, dull flatness is a fault, chalk and scale are faults — but the band of water that makes good coffee is wide, and where you sit inside it is a matter of taste. Fix the faults, brew two cups side by side, and let your mouth decide. That is the whole method, and it works without a single piece of equipment.

Back to the home page — or read Brewing for grind, ratio and the methods this water goes into, Storing coffee for keeping the beans as good as the water, and the Glossary for alkalinity, hardness and TDS in a sentence each.